I’ve read and watched so many of these Talking Point Memos, I could probably write one. All one needs do is use as many of the 7 types of propaganda techniques as possible.
With this post the Not Now Silly Newsroom tests the watters [geddit?] for a new series of Annotated Bill O’Reilly Talking Point Memos. Aunty Em used to do this over at NewsHounds with Glenn Beck’s Comedy Caliphate when he was still slinging the crazy over at the Fox “News” Channel. It’s a lot of fun and it usually got a good reaction. Let me know what you think. Weigh in and let me know whether I should continue.
In order to win the presidency in 2016 both the Republican and Democratic candidate will have to get a good amount of votes from Hispanic Americans.
But the leading GOP is doing everything in his power to drive them away. Therefore, you’ve got to make people afraid.
On Thanksgiving the New York Times ran an editorial that pretty much laid out what the liberal viewpoint is on people coming to live in America.
Of course, almost all the other times O’Reilly, or Fox “News,” mentions the NYTs it is to trash it. But, do go on. I’m fascinated to learn where this is going.
Point number one: The left no longer distinguishes between illegal aliens and those who come here legally.
Of course, you can show where the NYTs said exactly that, right? I thought not. I’ve done several searches and while this is not conclusive proof, I couldn’t find it. But, I’d be happy to link it HERE if anyone points it out to me.
All foreign nationals who enter are now described by the Times and others as immigrants.
All? That’s a sweeping statement. Even I hedged above when I said, “…almost all the other times O’Reilly, or Fox “News,” mentions the NYTs…” But, things are just Black and White to you, no pun intended.
And if you use the term illegal alien, you are a bigot.
Uh, oh! Someone must have called Loofah Lad a bigot recently.
Point two: The left believes that any fence on the southern border is nativist bigotry that is a hateful action towards non-Americans, especially Hispanics.
Any fence? Again, a sweeping statement. I don’t know anybody who is against a border fence. But, you’re just calling it a “fence” to cover for the GOP’s head bigot, Donald Trump, who wants to build a yuuuuuuuge wall to keep out all the rapists and criminals he talks about.
Point number three: The left wants open borders, no restrictions on those who come here, no detention, no physical barrier, no deportation proceedings unless a serious crime other than illegal entry is committed.
I have yet to hear anyone advocate that. Which orifice are you pulling your facts from?
And if you disagree with that you are a promoting an anti-immigrant police state.
We already have a police state. That’s what #BlackLivesMatter is all about.
Point four: The left says all immigrants — again illegal and legal — should be welcomed and assimilated.
Again, I have yet to hear anyone advocate for that. Altho’, I have heard people with good hearts talk about welcoming Syrian refugees. Is this what this is really about? Syrian refugees?
And not only that, the government should give them money to settle in and they should be immediately eligible for all the entitlements Americans can secure.
|An earlier Talking Point Memo delivered without a hint of irony|
You’re really pushing every negative and already debunked trope you can think of, ain’t you?
Point five: All illegal aliens already here should be put on a pathway to citizenship.
What is your proposal, Falafel King? You can’t deport them all. And, you can’t have a second tier of U.S. resident, where some immigrants are allowed to become citizens and others are not. I’d love to hear your proposal.
The left wants full amnesty.
The Rabid Right wants deportation. What’s the ‘Merkin thing to do? You’re a Catholic, Bill O. What would Jesus do?
And finally point number six: The left wants free lawyers for all immigrants so they can gather up the entitlements and citizenship requirements.
Actually, the Constitution requites lawyers. That whole “You have a right to remain silent” speech ends with an acknowledgment of that.
At the end of the editorial in the New York Times, the paper asks is that so radical?
Okay, I just went and looked again. I’ve not found the editorial you speak of. Could you just point it out to me so I can see how you’ve misquoted it, if it even exists at all.
The answer of course is yes, open borders, full amnesty, complete entitlement access is indeed radical and dangerous to public order and safety.
Be afraid! Be very Afraid!!
But that is the vision of the Democratic Party.
WAIT! I thought you said it was the entire Left Wing, but now it’s just the Democratic Party?
Not everyone, but you will not hear many Democrats go up against that, as the Kate’s Law debate demonstrated.
WAIT!!! You just said it was the entire Democratic Party. Which is it. Who are you talking about?
Now many believe this is a pure political strategy, that flooding the nation with foreigners — many of whom will get the right to vote — strengthens the Democratic Party.
|An earlier Talking Point Memo delivered without a hint of irony|
Call me crazy, but I think immigration strengthens the nation. But that’s just me.
But there is much more in play.
And, you’ll let us in on the secret of this Left Wing Cabal, right? I’m breathless with anticipation.
The radical left immigration vision would profoundly change all of America’s traditions, all of them.
WAIT!!! Now it’s just the radical left. Make up your mind. You can’t keep moving the target like this.
And that’s what the left wants because that ideology sees the American Judeo-Christian tradition as oppressive, exploitative and a white-privilege legacy.
Now this screed makes sense. I get it now. You’re worried about your precious White Privilege being taken away, ain’t you? You’re downright scared, ain’t you?
Thus, the uber-left wants traditional America wiped off the face of the earth.
WAIT!!! Now it’s just the uber-left? That’s the fringiest of the fringe. You’re scaremongering about those crazy outliers?
That’s what is truly going on and if Americans don’t wise up quickly, the left-wing vision of immigration may very well become a reality.
That’s not what’s going on at all. You pulled all of that out of your ass to create a strawman you’ve conditioned your brain-dead viewers to believe is their enemy.
And that’s the memo.
One of the biggest piles you’ve ever crapped out, which is why I decided to annotate it.
Not a single word of Loofah Lad’s has been omitted or changed. For comparison, the entire Talking Points Memo without annotation can be found here, because I show my work, unlike Loofah Lad.